Login  |  Register          Free Newsletter Subscription
Zibb
FREE subscription
Email
Print
Reprint
Learn RSS

Sweet Deal: Red Mango's Expansion

Red Mango rolls out its brand of tart frozen yogurt with a simple--and so far profitable--business model.

By David Farkas, Senior Editor -- Chain Leader, 10/1/2008

Serving up Red Mango yogurt
A worker fills a cup with Red Mango's tart-flavored, nonfat frozen yogurt. Seconds later, she'll add one of more than 19 toppings at the cusomer's request.
Red Mango Chief Operating Officer Jean Birch says she hasn't seen anything like it—and she's worked for some of the industry's most lucrative quick-service concepts including Pizza Hut, Taco Bell and Corner Bakery.

“It” being the difference between the cost of opening a Red Mango unit—anywhere from $263,000 to $364,000—and its annual sales volumes, which range between $700,000 and $1.2 million, according to the company. That difference likely translates into healthy unit-level cash flows even after subtracting franchise fees ($35,000) and royalties (8 percent of sales, including the advertising fund). The privately held company doesn't share full unit economics.

“The numbers tumble pretty well in this business, especially when you look at the level of complexity,” declares Birch, meaning the lack of hoods, stoves and long ingredient lists typical of fast-feeders. “This is a pretty straightforward business model.”

So far, the model has attracted franchisees in nine states that operate 24 of Red Mango's 36 units, all of which have opened since July 2007, a pace founder and CEO Dan Kim says is continuing this year and next. The company expects to open 30 units in 2009.

“We believe the [frozen yogurt] market is very hot and will remain very hot for a couple of years,” says Korean-born Kim.

Unless you've been visiting another planet, you're aware frozen-yogurt chains have been popping up with the regularity of ragweed, chiefly in areas where young and style-conscious consumers hang out. Red Mango opened its first store in the trendy Westwood neighborhood of Los Angeles. Today 70 percent of Red Mango's customers are female, no doubt drawn by the no-fat and low-calorie product.

Red Mango will exploit the trend by developing company and franchise units in existing markets rather than entering new ones. Seattle and San Francisco, the company's highest volume markets, will get the most attention in coming months, Kim adds.

New Management Team

To help expand the chain, an outgrowth of Korea's 140-unit Red Mango chain, Kim recently hired Birch, who is overseeing development and building an infrastructure to manage franchise and company stores, and Chief Marketing Officer Jim Notarnicola, a veteran of Blockbuster and 7-Eleven. At press time Kim was looking for a chief financial officer.

Red Mango's yogurt
Red Mango's yogurt contains microbial cultures dubbed "probiotics" that may be beneficial to one's health.
Such executive timber is the result of landing a $12 million private placement from CIC Capital Partners in Dallas, led by CIC Operating Partner and former Taco Bell Chairman John Antioco. Now Red Mango's chairman, he says the return-on-investment could be in the 20-plus range, though he adds, “I'm not ready to define the 'plus' just yet.”

The new capital isn't destined for unit growth. “We won't necessarily be deploying that capital on bricks and mortar,” Kim says. “I want to build a management team and spend the money more strategically on advertising.”

Building the Brand

Like other entreprenuers, Kim has spent few dollars on marketing, gaining brand awareness chiefly through viral marketing and sponsoring local events. Red Mango recently supported a Korean-American Bar Association meeting and NBC Summer Press Day.

Kim wants to do more of the same but also add traditional media to the mix. “Now that we have money, we will focus our efforts on more interactive marketing and print,” says Kim.

Brand awareness is also the result of market penetration. Red Mango has already jumped across the country to New York City, where a franchisee operates seven stores, and suburban Chicago. Other markets include Seattle, Salt Lake City, San Francisco and Los Angeles. The Sherman Oaks, Calif.-based company is a registered franchisor in 15 states, according to a franchise circular on file with the California Department of Corporations.

“Most of those cities have large populations that are very health conscious and active,” Kim explains. “They're also educated and love to keep abreast of things that are new, especially in Seattle where it rains a lot. They love hanging out in a relaxing environment.” What about Salt Lake City? “There are not a lot of destinations that are stylish, and people there don't drink a lot of coffee.”

Red Mango interior

Sleek decors help account for the concept’s attraction and hefty volumes.

A 'Froyo' Stampede

The market for frozen yogurt is being driven by a consumer eager for healthful snacks and quiet places to spend time. Frozen yogurt, especially the tart (as opposed to sweet) variety, can contain live microbial cultures dubbed “probiotics” that may be beneficial to digestion. Some so-called frozen yogurts do not contain live cultures. It doesn't hurt, either, that green tea is one of two flavors Red Mango offers; the other is “original,” a plain yogurt. Sixteen toppings keep things interesting.

In Kim's many TV appearances, he almost never fails to mention Red Mango's frozen yogurt is “authentic,” meaning it contains enough live cultures to rate a seal of approval as real yogurt from the National Yogurt Association. Pinkberry, after an embarrassing episode this spring involving a lawsuit charging its products did not contain enough live cultures to warrant calling it yogurt, now boasts the same seal of approval.

As Birch suggests, there is little complexity. Red Mango's proprietary tart yogurt product is thawed to liquid consistency in the unit before being added to soft-serve machines.

Kim isn't worried about two-year-old Pinkberry, now backed by Maveron, Starbucks CEO and Chairman Howard Schultz's venture-capital firm. Kim says 60-unit, Los Angeles-based Pinkberry attracts a different crowd: “younger and narrower.” Since opening the first unit, he adds, he's learned Red Mango's audience isn't merely trendy. “Red Mango works well outside of Los Angeles,” he says.

Keeping Them Coming

Red Mango staffer

How long the craze for “froyo” remains popular is anyone’s guess. But if the largest players, namely, Red Mango and Pinkberry, can franchise their way among active and educated people, the product may be around longer than the last round.

Yet what's to keep traditional ice cream shops or fast feeders from jumping on this trend? Hipness, in a word. Both Red Mango and Pinkberry, taking their cue from the success of highly designed Starbucks, have paid particular attention to interiors. Customers rest their tushes in Philippe Starck chairs at Pinkberry. Intimacy is the rule at Red Mango. “We like creating these zones of privacy,” Kim explains. ”I call them friendship booths.”

A more pressing concern to investors is how long the lust for frozen yogurt lasts. In its last incarnation, from the early to mid-'90s, interest flagged after bad publicity. “There was a big rise in the number of stores, and they were successful for a while, and then nutritionists began pointing out the caloric content. Turns out, it wasn't all that different from ice cream,” recalls Bob Yonkers, chief economist for the International Dairy Foods Association in Washington, D.C.

The result: Americans consume a mere 1.3 pounds of frozen yogurt per capita annually, down from 3.5 pounds in 1993, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

Trend-watcher Richard Laermer dismisses the current round as another fad. “Problem with all these expensive yogurt stores is they all want to be hip. You cannot manufacture that sentiment,” argues the author of 2011: Trendspotting for the Next Decade. “Even Pinkberry is becoming a joke, and now that the masses are going to it, it's slowly becoming as passé as something that was cool yesterday.”

Not so, Antioco insists: “This time is different because we believe the healthier-for-you trend, as long as the product provides satisfaction in the right kind of environment, will be around for a long time.”

Unit to Unit: Red Mango vs. Pinkberry
Pinkberry Red Mango
Revenues $1.7 million to $3.0 million* $700,000 to $1.2 million
Units 60 36
Investment cost $343,300 to $1.0 million $263,500 to $364,000
Franchise fee** $40,000 $35,000
Royalty/ad fund 7.0% 8.0%
Protected trade area none 3 miles
*Chain Leader estimate; **Single-store franchise

 

Snapshot

Concept Red Mango

Headquarters Sherman Oaks, Calif.

Units 12 company, 24 franchised

2008 Systemwide Sales $28 million*

Average Unit Volume $700,000 to $1.2 million

Average Check $6

Expansion Plans 30 in 2009

*Chain Leader estimate

Email
Print
Reprint
Learn RSS

Talkback

We would love your feedback!

Post a comment

» VIEW ALL TALKBACK THREADS

Related Content

Related Content

 

By This Author

Sponsored Links

 
Advertisement

More Content

  • Blogs
  • Podcasts

Blogs

  • David Farkas
    Dave's Dispatch

    December 1, 2008
    Are you celebrating Christmas or the holidays?
    Tis' the season, no? So I assume restaurant operators will encourage the troops to deck their restaurants' halls with balls of holly and, pe......
    More
  • Lane Cardwell
    The Next Big Thing

    November 30, 2008
    Fighting Gravity
    The restaurant industry has had close ties to gravity since the day that Sir Isaac Newton saw an apple fall from a tree and wondered why it fel......
    More
  • View All BlogsRSS

Podcasts

Advertisements





NEWSLETTERS

Get restaurant industry news, trends and business-critical information delivered directly to your inbox!

Chain Leader Executive Briefing (Twice Monthly)
Newsfeed (Daily)
Quick Service Reporter (Monthly)
eMarketplace (Monthly)
About Us   |   Advertising Info   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us   |   FREE Subscription   |   Useful Sites   |   RSS   |   Help
© 2008 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Please visit these other Reed Business sites